Do you need to edit your work, and you’re torn between doing so on Grammarly or ProProWritingAid? Perhaps you use one of the two products and want to switch.
Both grammar and spell checkers have many outstanding features, so we get why you may be undecided about the two.
It doesn’t have to be difficult, though. It all depends on your needs. In this article, we’ll make a comparison of ProProWritingAid VS Grammarly.
We’ll examine their features and the type of writers they’re suited to and compare their accuracy and price.
- ProWritingAid vs Grammarly Overview
- ProWritingAid vs Grammarly Accuracy
- Grammarly vs ProWritingAid Who They’re Best For
- ProWritingAid vs Grammarly Price
- Which is Better?
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Wrapping Up
ProWritingAid vs Grammarly Overview
Let’s quickly examine both checkers to see what they do and how they work.
What is ProWritingAid and How Does it Work?
ProWritingAid is a grammar and spell checker that provides recommendations to correct your errors. The tool also gives 20 reports for you to analyze and improve your writing.
Some of these reports include overused words, grammar, writing style, clichés and redundancies, readability, dialogue tags, consistency, transition, and 12 others.
How Does ProWritingAid Work?
You can type directly into the editor or copy your work from Microsoft Word or Google Doc into the interface. The ProWritingAid software will highlight words, phrases, and punctuation issues needing improvements.
On the left sidebar are two tabs for “Goals” and “Improvements.” You’ll have to click “Improvements” to see suggested ways to refine your texts.
What is Grammarly and How Does it Work?
Grammarly is perhaps the most popular grammar checker. Like ProWritingAid, Grammarly has a web editor you can write in or copy text into.
For every new document on Grammarly, you must set goals across four pillars.
These pillars include Audience (general, knowledgeable, or expert), formality (formal, informal, or neutral), domain (academic, business, casual, general, email, and creative), and intent (inform, describe, convince, and tell a story).
You can see your overall content score on the right sidebar alongside the number of corrections remaining and how clear and engaging the text is.
ProWritingAid vs Grammarly Accuracy
Accuracy is perhaps the most important factor when choosing a grammar or spell-checking tool.
Accuracy comes in two folds, identifying errors correctly and then providing accurate recommendations.
Let’s see how the two tools fare.
How Accurate is ProWritingAid?
During our test – with three different texts – we consistently found that ProWritingAid provided more alerts than Grammarly. It didn’t catch our British spelling of “fibre,” which should have been fiber.
On a few occasions, it also provided some not so accurate for our purposely misspelled words like “plugin.” For example, the tool suggested polygon, plugging, and plucking as possible replacements for “plguin.”
That said, ProWritingAid helped trim the fat from our texts by accurately suggesting we remove fluff from our writeups.
Overall, ProWritingAid is very accurate, especially in catching most errors. Its strength is in making your text more readable and improving the flow.
How Accurate is Grammarly?
While Grammarly didn’t list as many errors as ProWritingAid during our tests, we agreed with and accepted many of its suggestions. Unlike ProWritingAid, it caught our non-American variant of “fiber.”
Be certain that Grammarly will identify more errors than Microsoft Word and most other checkers. Its ability with homophones is unmatched. It cited and corrected eminent to imminent.
Perhaps one factor that works in Grammarly’s favor is that it’s a market leader in the space. This factor means that its algorithm gets more texts to learn and improve.
That said, language and grammar are complex, with unlimited word combinations. This complexity makes it difficult for any grammar checker to be 100% accurate.
Grammarly vs ProWritingAid Who They’re Best For
Both Grammarly and ProWritingAid have their strengths and are two of the best grammar checkers. Below, we examine who they are best suited for.
Who ProWritingAid is Good For
The ProWritingAid editor can accept and process more than 100,000 words at a go without a major reduction in the site’s performance. This ability makes it readily useful for fiction writing.
Furthermore, ProWritingAid provides dialogue tags and repeat check reports that further make it more tailored to long-form writing.
Is ProWritingAid Good for Academic Writing?
Most grammar checkers struggle with academic writing. They all have lesser accuracy with texts that have more complicated verbiage. The artificial intelligence of grammar checkers requires a lot of input to improve its accuracy.
Hence, the algorithm must be trained on a large volume of law text to correct a law text accurately.
So, a grammar checker may perform great with medical texts and do poorly with mathematics thesis because it hasn’t been properly “trained” in the latter.
ProWritingAid has been around since 2011 and has over 2 million users, enough time, and many users to improve its base algorithm beyond simple language.
Our verdict is that ProWritingAid is more than adequate for academic writing. In particular, it’ll help you fix errors like complex paragraphs, poor sentence structure and transitions between ideas, and much more.
Who Grammarly is Good For
Grammarly is perfect for online writing, such as blog posts and social media. It’s also great for businesses, writing marketing copy, emails, presentations, and reports.
With a large user base and many years in operation, Grammarly is also suited to academic writing.
Also, it’s important to note that the Grammarly editor begins to suffer performance issues once you hit 10,000 words and above. So, it’s not suited to long-form writing like that.
ProWritingAid vs Grammarly Price
Price is another essential factor for most people when choosing tools. Let’s examine the paid and free variants of both tools.
If you’re paying for the ProWritingAid premium plan every month, you’ll pay $30 per month. However, if you pay for the premium plan yearly, you’ll only have to pay $120.
Unlike Grammarly, ProWritingAid also has a $399 one-time payment for lifetime access. Register for a free trial of ProWritingAid to see if it’s what you’re looking for in a grammar checker.
ProWritingAid Free Version
There’s a free ProWritingAid version that offers you limited access to the editor and some features. There is a 500-word limit and only ten rephrases per day on the free tier.
You won’t have access to advanced style improvements, unlimited word count and rephrases, plagiarism checker, custom style guide, author comparison, citations, collaborations, and much more.
Take advantage of the company’s free trial to access premium features for 14 days.
Like ProWritingAid, Grammarly has a monthly plan priced at $30. You can also opt for the quarterly and annual plans and pay $20 and $12 monthly, respectively.
Businesses can also register an account for their team. This plan is worth $15 per month and comes with additional features such as brand tones, a style guide, account roles and permissions, and an analytics dashboard.
Grammarly Free Version
Grammarly’s free version only comes with corrections for grammar, spelling mistakes, punctuation, conciseness, and tone detection. It also offers auto-citations for academic writing.
Which is Better?
Here’s the crux of the matter: which is better among the two grammar and spell checkers?
Is ProWritingAid Better than Grammarly?
Overall, Grammarly is the better writing tool. However, the gap is not as overwhelming as you think. Grammarly trumps ProWritingAid in two critical areas:
1. Interface and design: The Grammarly app has a more intuitive and user-friendly interface than ProWritingAid. ProWritingAid can improve the sidebar that houses the improvements tab.
2. Accuracy: Grammarly’s recommendations are more accurate than those of ProWritingAid. One reason I think this is so is because of the many years Grammarly has been in operation and its number of users. These two factors have allowed Grammarly to sharpen its algorithm better than ProWritingAid and other alternatives to Grammarly.
In the spirit of fairness, I think ProWritingAid beats Grammarly in terms of the number of features available on the free version, integrations, and pricing.
Frequently Asked Questions
We’ve answered additional questions on this topic below.
Is Grammarly Better Than PowerPoint?
PowerPoint is not a grammar checker, although it can highlight some common grammar and spelling errors like Google Docs.
Grammarly, on the other hand, is an advanced grammar and spell checker capable of catching all the kinds of mistakes that PowerPoint can’t.
Do Professional Writers Use ProWritingAid?
Professional writers use ProWritingAid like they would other grammar checkers like Grammarly.
They’re aware that these tools may not catch all the grammar and contextual errors but use it to correct common mistakes to fast-track the editing process.
Grammarly and ProWritingAid are two popular and feature-rich grammar checkers.
While the latter is more suited to fiction writers, the former is superb for online writing, marketing copy, and business writing.
In terms of which is better, Grammarly slightly edges ProWritingAid because of its superior accuracy and intuitive user interface and design.
ProWritingAid is cheaper, though, and has some additional features than Grammarly.
Do you want to know more about any of these tools? Let us know in the comment section, and we’ll reach out ASAP.